Rent With Integrity, LLC - Tallahassee, Florida

Gina L.

Rent With Integrity is a great company to rent with. We have rented with them for over 4 years in two different rentals and have no complaints whatsoever with any of their services. Danielle, the property manager, is great with communication and assistance with anything that we need and maintenance is completed timely.
In our current rental, the kitchen cabinets and counters were worn down and coming off of the wall and needed to be replaced. Thanks to the owner of the home and Rent With Integrity, we had all of the cabinets and countertops replaced with brand new versions. The whole job was completed in only a little over a week and it looks great. Electricians, plumbers, and maintenance techs were all called quickly to get the last details finished so we were not without a kitchen for long at all, which was so greatly appreciated.
Definitely recommend renting with them if you have the opportunity!

Noel D.

I recently had the pleasure of renting through Rent with Integrity in Tallahassee, and I can't recommend them highly enough! Danielle was a fantastic representative—friendly, knowledgeable, and incredibly patient with all my questions. She took the time to explain everything in detail and made sure I felt comfortable with my decisions.

What I appreciated most was her honesty; it was clear that she genuinely cared about finding the right fit for me rather than just securing a sale. This level of integrity is rare in the rental market, and it made my experience truly enjoyable.

If you're looking for a quality, seamless renting experience, I wholeheartedly recommend Rent with Integrity. You won’t be disappointed!

Rachel L.

My partner and I resided with Rent with Integrity for 3 years, I’m not sure where to begin with the amount of issues we’ve encountered. During the inquiry/move in process, communication was on par, management responded to emails and texts very quickly. Although Theresa was very rude and snarky, I did not see that as a red flag at the time. When it came to any concerns, especially during the move out process, Danielle the property manager would not return any calls, emails, or texts especially regarding the outrageous charges they took from our security deposit and then the overages.
They charged us $300 for “Cleaning”.
They would not specify what exactly needed to be cleaned. After reading reviews from previous tenants, we moved our stuff out of the house 2 weeks prior of the move out date, slept on an air mattress, cleaned and scrubbed everything down to ensure we would not encounter the same negative experience as previous tenants. The only thing that would cause the house to need cleaning afterward was the dust from ducts that needed to be cleaned, and BLACK MOLD that we were made responsible for. Mold accumulated so fast in that house due to the windows that were so old there was a constant draft, and was the reason we had to move. The mold issue was brought to the attention of the staff, to which they said there was nothing they could do about it.
We were charged over $900 for the paint job, again, was also not specified, but I can assume it was for patching nail holes, and natural accumulation after 3 years that is to be expected when you use flat paint.
The homes that Rent with Integrity manage are thrown together as cheaply as possible. Cheap flat paint, old windows, soft spots in floors for some homes, and inefficient HVAC/windows (causing high utility bills). I can say that is not just in my experience, but after seeing some of the other homes they manage, it shows they are proficient in the “Landlord’s special” with a lot of their properties.
Please save yourself the money and the headache and continue your search for a home elsewhere.

Adam S.

Absolutely a blessing from God. I was able to view a property Tuesday, sign a lease Thursday, and start moving in on Friday. All while over Christmas week. This team is incredible and helped me be able to make this possible. Customer service 10/10, made me feel welcome from when I walked in and through the entire process. Also, they are animal lovers which is not always the case when dealing with property management companies. Actually gave me a hassle for not bringing in my Husky to meet them. (All jokes!) All in all, I definitely recommend them based on my experience so far!

Shameka B.

Do yourself a favor and never rent from this company they will mislead you. I moved in with things needing to be fixed on a walk thru with RJ on a Friday who promised the things would be fixed Monday. Two months later I'm still waiting on the things to be fixed I've called Danielle and Rj several times and every time I call they will send a text saying their in a meeting which is bs. If you call the office your on hold for a whole hour only to be told by the recording to call back at a later time. I have broken closet doors, a room with no lights, I was told I had to pay an $50 for services not rendered I was told maintenance would change the air filter going on 3 months and that has yet to happen. I went out and brought my own filter because the utility bill is sky high because of the dirty filter. PLEASE DO NOT RENT FROM THIS COMPANY. Pictures of the filter is posted.

Ben L.

We rented from them for 4 years. They weren't terrible, but they were cheap.
When appliances broke they were replaced quickly, but with bottom-of-the-line models. They once had a contractor out to check for things to fix. However, they didn't like what he suggested so they brought in a second one. This second one agreed with the first, but they didn't want to fix things so they just didn't.
We also had to wait more than 3 months to get our security deposit back because they sent it to the apartment we just moved out of, despite at least 4 emails providing our new address (this kind of shows you how well they're run).

I'm guessing that they have some kind of giveaway to new residents if they leave a review which is why you see so many recent 5-star ones. I'd suggest disregarding all of those and looking at any that are 1-4 stars.

In short, they're a property management company. They're here to make as much money off of you as possible. They'll raise your rent, make as few repairs as they're legally required to, be kind of a pain to deal with, and try to keep your security deposit. But, they could be a lot worse.

Emanuel O.

If you’re looking for a good place in tallahassee, start here! Both Kevin and Danielle were extremely kind people who took the extra step for me to secure a place in my time of need. No doubt, these are the best people to go to if you’re looking to rent with integrity.

Evana P.

Terrible property management company! Do not rent from or trust these people to manage your property! We're a military family and my husband recieved orders to temporaily relocate, being that I am pregnant and we have a baby and a young child we didn't want to be apart for that timeframe, so we decided not to sell our home since it was only temporary hence the decision to rent it out. We made the mistake of trusting Rent with Integrity to take care of and manage our family home. They neglected our house and didn't even check on it and ignored my efforts reaching out to them to see how the house was doing. Finally, we asked my family (who already had spare keys to the house) to check on it instead and they discovered the lawn was in disarray and that there was an attempted break-in with the lockbox and items inside the house were broken. Rent With Integrity completely neglected the property. This company demanded we pay $650 for a list of maintenance items, including fixing an outlet, 1 blind, and applying touch-up paint, the other items they charged us for they never did the work for yet they gladly took the money. They took the money and left the inside of our house with mismatched touch-up paint, a taken down blind, and instead of fixing an outlet they just covered it up. Pictures speak for themselves! Do not trust these people. They are super shady! They have had so many other issues, the list goes on! Feel free to contact me directly if you want more details.